At a time when artificial intelligence (AI) has become almost synonymous with technology, it’s hard to believe that there are organizations yet to get on the bandwagon. But according to a recent Mercer survey, 30% of HR leaders are avoiding AI altogether. The problem? They’re struggling to extract meaningful value from AI deployments and questioning whether the technology lives up to its promises.
Of those that have implemented AI, more than half (56%) of HR teams admit they’re not confident in their tech-optimization efforts, and only 4% say their tech stacks are optimized for the best results. This has unearthed a troubling trend in HR: those that aren’t skipping out on AI aren’t seeing real value from their efforts. Fortune has dubbed this an “AI confidence crisis.” And it’s very likely HR isn’t the only industry feeling the pain.
This admission isn’t entirely surprising. HR still lacks its “killer app” moment—the breakthrough AI solution that opens the floodgates for broader adoption, much like Lotus 1-2-3 did for PCs. Without this defining moment, many HR professionals find themselves caught between the fear of missing out and the reality of underwhelming implementations.
However, the risk of inaction may be greater than the risk of imperfect execution. While the competitive threat varies—larger digital enterprises face more immediate pressure than smaller businesses, for example—the fundamental danger remains. Those who fail to adopt AI will be outpaced by competitors or become obsolete.
4 Principles for AI Adoption
For HR professionals grappling with this confidence crisis, there’s good news: you don’t need to reinvent the wheel to evaluate AI tools. In fact, it can be simpler than most organizations make it out to be. What it comes down to is keeping the business need and your organizational goals top of mind. Here are four strategic approaches to do this:
1.) Focus on Challenges, Not Technology: The most common mistake in AI adoption is starting with the technology rather than the problem you’re trying to solve for. Instead of specifically seeking AI solutions, identify specific challenges within your HR operations—whether it’s improving candidate screening, reducing time-to-hire, or enhancing employee engagement. If the best solution happens to be AI-powered, that’s great. But AI alone should never be the goal itself. Solving real business problems should be.
2.) Embrace Imperfection: Most AI solutions are non-deterministic, meaning they can produce incorrect or inconsistent results. This often stops organizations from seeing the value, but it shouldn’t. Humans also make mistakes, and the comparison should be between AI performance and human performance, not between AI and perfection. If an AI resume screening tool is 90% accurate compared to a human recruiter’s 75% accuracy, that represents a meaningful improvement, even if it’s not flawless.
3.) Consider the Human Element: When contemplating AI replacements for human tasks, ask a crucial question: What uniquely human elements might be lost? HR work often involves empathy, cultural understanding, and nuanced judgment—qualities that remain difficult for AI to replicate. If you’re automating processes that traditionally involve these human touches, ensure you’re prepared for what might be sacrificed. Have strategies to preserve critical human connections where they matter most.
4.) Demand Transparency from Vendors: Reject black-box AI solutions. Reputable vendors should readily explain their training data sources, model usage, and bias prevention measures. This transparency isn’t just about understanding the technology—it’s about ensuring compliance, managing risk, and making informed decisions about implementation. If a vendor can’t or won’t provide these details, consider it a red flag.
An example of real AI applications driving value to HR, Consider resume screening. Typically, the first step in any recruiting process, this has traditionally been a time-consuming task for junior staff. AI-powered screening tools can now handle this function more accurately than humans, with less bias and fewer errors. By eliminating tedious screening tasks, recruiters can focus their energy on what AI can’t: building relationships and applying uniquely human judgment to complex hiring decisions.
While some apprehension about AI replacing job functions may feed into the bigger (albeit overblown) fear that AI will soon take our jobs, there are very few industries where this is imminent. The purpose of AI (for now) is to streamline operations and take the drudgery out of mundane but necessary job tasks. Will it change the job role? Sure—and if we’re doing it right, for the better. And that starts with smart AI implementations.
The key to overcoming HR’s AI confidence crisis lies not in blind adoption or complete avoidance, but in thoughtful, strategic implementation. Start small, measure results against realistic benchmarks, and always keep business outcomes at the center of your AI strategy. The organizations that will succeed won’t necessarily be the first to adopt every shiny new tool, but rather those that thoughtfully and strategically implement the technology.
Stay ahead of the curve. Subscribe to HRTechEdge for your competitive edge.
