When the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics finally released its delayed October/November 2025 Employment Situation report, the headline numbers didn’t inspire much confidence. Payroll employment fell by 105,000 jobs in October, rebounded modestly with a 64,000 gain in November, and the unemployment rate climbed to a four-year high of 4.6%. For anyone scanning the topline data, the signal looked familiar: a cooling labor market, cautious employers, and mounting uncertainty.
But that’s only half the story.
What the BLS still doesn’t measure—and what’s increasingly driving real economic output—is the extended workforce: contractors, independent professionals, statement-of-work consultants, and project-based talent operating outside traditional payrolls. According to Beeline, a leading extended workforce management platform, this “invisible” segment now accounts for roughly 40% of the total U.S. workforce. And by Beeline’s own data, it’s not slowing down at all.
A Labor Market the BLS Doesn’t See
The BLS Employment Situation report is designed to track full-time and part-time payroll jobs. It’s a valuable benchmark, but one rooted in a 20th-century definition of work. Today’s most in-demand skills—digital transformation, AI implementation, cybersecurity, data engineering, specialized healthcare, and complex project delivery—are increasingly delivered by non-payroll talent.
Beeline’s anonymized and aggregated platform data, covering October 1 through November 30, 2025, paints a very different picture from the payroll slowdown implied by the BLS report.
Here’s what Beeline is seeing across its global customer base:
-
Hours billed by extended workforce talent rose 3.5% in October and 5.1% in November year over year.
-
60% of Beeline customers increased their use of external labor during this period.
-
Assignment starts climbed 4.9%, while assignment ends declined 0.5%, signaling forward momentum rather than retrenchment.
-
Assignments increased in 45 countries, with the United States leading growth.
-
Spending on flexible talent rose 6.2% year over year, as organizations redirected budgets toward non-traditional workforce strategies.
In other words, while payroll jobs wobbled, work itself didn’t disappear—it migrated.
Why Companies Are Doubling Down on External Talent
This shift isn’t just a short-term reaction to economic uncertainty. It reflects a deeper structural change in how organizations access skills.
Hiring full-time employees remains expensive, slow, and risky in volatile markets. Extended workforce models offer a different equation: faster access to specialized expertise, variable cost structures, and the ability to scale up or down without long-term commitments. For CIOs, CHROs, and procurement leaders under pressure to deliver results with tighter budgets, that flexibility is hard to ignore.
Beeline’s data suggests companies aren’t merely experimenting with contractors—they’re actively expanding their reliance on them. The rise in assignment starts combined with a decline in assignment ends indicates confidence, not caution. Organizations are initiating new projects and extending ongoing ones, particularly in skill-intensive roles that don’t map neatly to permanent headcount.
This also aligns with broader enterprise trends. Digital transformation initiatives continue even when hiring freezes hit HR dashboards. AI deployments, ERP modernizations, and cybersecurity programs don’t pause just because payroll numbers soften. They shift to alternative labor channels.
Independent Work Goes Mainstream
On the supply side, the extended workforce is growing just as fast.
According to the 2025 MBO Partners State of Independence report, 72.9 million Americans now work independently, with full-time independents nearly doubling since 2020—from about 13.6 million to 27.6 million. Collectively, they contribute more than $1 trillion annually to the U.S. economy.
That’s not a fringe labor pool. It’s a parallel economy.
What’s changed since the pandemic years is permanence. Independent work is no longer a stopgap between traditional jobs; for millions, it’s the job. High-skill professionals are choosing independence for autonomy, compensation potential, and flexibility, while companies are meeting them there with better tools, platforms, and governance models.
Beeline sits squarely at this intersection, managing compliance, sourcing, visibility, and spend across a workforce most enterprises still struggle to quantify.
Rethinking Labor Market Health
Doug Leeby, CEO of Beeline, argues that focusing solely on payroll jobs misses the point of how work actually happens today.
“As the largest independent extended workforce platform in the world, we see a part of the labor market that the jobs report does not measure,” Leeby said. “The reality is that work is not slowing, it is shifting.”
That shift has implications far beyond quarterly earnings calls. Policymakers relying on payroll employment as a proxy for economic health may underestimate resilience—or misdiagnose weakness. Organizations planning workforce strategies based only on headcount risk underinvesting in the infrastructure needed to manage non-employee labor effectively. And analysts forecasting labor shortages or surpluses may be looking at the wrong dataset.
The Competitive Edge of Visibility
One of the quieter takeaways from Beeline’s data is the growing importance of visibility. As extended workforce usage expands, managing it with spreadsheets or disconnected vendor systems becomes untenable. Spend rises, compliance risk increases, and strategic insight disappears.
Platforms like Beeline are increasingly positioned not just as operational tools, but as intelligence layers—surfacing trends that traditional labor statistics miss entirely. In a market where nearly half the workforce operates outside payroll, that intelligence becomes a competitive advantage.
The Bottom Line
The October/November 2025 BLS report suggests a labor market losing momentum. Beeline’s data suggests something else entirely: a labor market in transition.
Payroll jobs may be stalling, but work is moving—toward flexibility, specialization, and independence. For enterprises willing to adapt, the extended workforce isn’t a workaround. It’s the strategy.
And for anyone trying to understand where the labor economy is really headed, it may be time to look beyond payroll.
Join thousands of HR leaders who rely on HRTechEdge for the latest in workforce technology, AI-driven HR solutions, and strategic insights
