AI in HR: Companies See the Value, But Leadership Alignment Lags

A new study from global talent solutions provider AMS, in partnership with Wakefield Research, paints a picture of a workplace caught between optimism and uncertainty over AI. While business leaders largely agree that AI is now critical to staying competitive in talent acquisition, nearly half say their HR teams and C-suite are not aligned on how to implement it effectively.

The survey of 300 CHROs, C-suite executives, and HR decision-makers reveals a widening gap between AI’s perceived strategic importance and its practical adoption. Although 89% of companies report they are not yet using AI across all major talent acquisition functions, 71% believe their organization should be investing more in AI for hiring.

The AI Alignment Challenge

Leadership views diverge sharply:

• 64% of all respondents believe their talent pool will not remain competitive without AI.

• CHROs lead the charge, with 80% emphasizing AI’s importance for the workforce.

• Yet 47% report misalignment between HR teams and the C-suite on AI’s role in recruitment.

“This research makes clear that alignment is lagging behind capabilities,” said Gordon Stuart, CEO of AMS. “Without a coordinated approach between HR and the C-suite, organizations risk falling behind in a competitive talent market where speed, skill visibility, and ethical decision-making will increasingly be shaped by AI.”

Workforce Concerns and Opportunities

Even as AI adoption rises, concerns persist:

• 70% worry AI will impact job security, with CHROs expressing the most concern (79%).

• 53% expect to hire more AI-savvy HR leaders over the next two years to manage the transition.

The survey highlights a workforce split: employees and leaders recognize AI’s efficiency benefits but are wary of disruption. The tension underscores the importance of strategic planning and communication in AI integration.

Skills Gaps Are Pushing AI Adoption

AI adoption is being driven less by cost-cutting and more by skills shortages and efficiency demands:

• 75% cite skills gaps as a major barrier to attracting top talent.

• 67% say efficiency, not cost, is the main driver for AI in hiring.

• 43% expect most or all talent acquisition processes to be handled primarily by AI by 2026, though human judgment remains critical, particularly for assessing soft skills.

The findings suggest that AI is sharpening human decision-making rather than replacing it. Companies increasingly see AI as a tool for enhancing insight and productivity while retaining the human touch.

Ethical AI Adoption Gains Traction

Encouragingly, companies are establishing ethical guardrails:

• 88% have formal ethical AI guidelines, with CHROs leading adoption at 93%.

• 87% believe candidates can ethically use AI to enhance résumés.

• Only 12% lack any formal ethical framework.

This demonstrates a maturing approach to AI in HR, balancing speed and innovation with fairness, transparency, and accountability.

“As we begin 2026, C-suites and the talent industry are knee-deep in strategizing AI’s impact,” said Stuart. “Leaders integrating ethical AI into talent processes now will outpace peers as AI fluency and measurable value continue to grow.”

Key Takeaways

1. AI is essential, but nearly half of companies face leadership misalignment.

2. Skills gaps and efficiency pressures are driving adoption faster than strategy or governance can keep up.

3. Human judgment remains vital, especially for soft skills.

4. Ethical guidelines are becoming standard, with CHROs leading the way.

For organizations navigating the AI talent revolution, the message is clear: alignment, ethics, and practical adoption will define which companies win the race for talent in the coming years.

Join thousands of HR leaders who rely on HRTechEdge for the latest in workforce technology, AI-driven HR solutions, and strategic insights