HomeEmployee ExperienceSingapore HR Reviews May Overlook a Key Burnout Risk

Singapore HR Reviews May Overlook a Key Burnout Risk

As Singapore employers prepare for year-end performance reviews, Strengths School founder Jason Ho is urging managers to look beyond competency scores and identify employees who perform well but feel depleted by their work. The company argues that this overlooked mismatch can put high-performing employees at risk of burnout and resignation.

Its Primal Greatness framework distinguishes between work employees are both good at and energised by, and work they can perform competently but find draining. The distinction challenges a common assumption in performance management: that strong results necessarily indicate a role or task is a good long-term fit.

The warning arrives at a consequential point in Singapore’s corporate calendar. Year-end appraisals often influence compensation, promotion decisions and development plans. Yet a review process focused mainly on whether an employee meets targets may overlook whether the work itself is sustainable.

ManpowerGroup’s 2026 Global Talent Barometer found that 72% of surveyed workers in Singapore had recently experienced burnout. The survey gathered responses from 515 workers in Singapore between September 1 and October 1, 2025. It also found that 73% were actively exploring new opportunities, even though 60% intended to remain with their current employer. The combination suggests that stated intentions to stay do not necessarily mean employees are settled or satisfied.

Research discussed in Harvard Business Review adds another dimension. A study by researchers including Yale’s Julia Moeller found that nearly one in five employees in a representative U.S. workforce sample were both highly engaged and highly burned out. This group also reported strong intentions to leave their organizations. The finding challenges the assumption that high engagement automatically protects employees from burnout. It does not establish that every highly engaged, burned-out employee will resign, but it does identify a workforce segment managers should not overlook.

Strengths School founder Jason Ho argues that conventional appraisal forms are poorly equipped to identify this risk. In his view, managers often assess whether someone performs a task effectively without asking whether the task gives the employee energy or steadily depletes it.

“Review season is followed by bonus season. Bonus season is followed by resignation season,” Ho said. He argues that employees who receive strong ratings can still be considering a move if their day-to-day responsibilities are draining.

Distinguishing capability from energy

Strengths School’s Primal Greatness framework is built around two questions: what a person does well, and what energises them. The company describes work that employees perform competently and find energising as “Primal Greatness”—the area where managers should look to develop and deploy their strengths.

It calls work that employees do well but find draining “Hollow Endeavor.” The distinction is intended to separate a genuine strength from a learned competency that may have become a source of stress. An employee who consistently produces accurate reports, for example, may be rated highly for analytical work even if the process leaves them exhausted or disengaged.

The framework does not suggest that every difficult task should be removed from an employee’s role. Most jobs include routine, demanding or less enjoyable responsibilities. Its practical implication is that managers should understand the balance between energising work and draining work, particularly when an employee’s performance remains high despite signs of strain.

That distinction could influence how HR teams structure development conversations. Instead of relying exclusively on performance ratings, managers could ask which responsibilities employees want to do more often, which tasks consume disproportionate energy, and whether their current role makes enough use of their strongest capabilities.

The manager’s role in appraisal quality

The second issue raised by Ho concerns the consistency of performance reviews. A widely cited Journal of Applied Psychology study by Steven Scullen, Michael Mount and Maynard Goff examined performance ratings across two large datasets. It found that individual rater effects accounted for 62% of rating variance in one dataset and 53% in the other. General and job-dimension performance together accounted for 21% and 25%, respectively.

The figures do not mean that 62% of all performance reviews are inaccurate. They show that the identity and tendencies of the person giving a rating can substantially influence the score. For employers, that creates a challenge: appraisal outcomes may reflect differences in managerial judgment as well as differences in employee performance.

Manager training, clearer rating criteria and calibration discussions can help organizations reduce inconsistent evaluations. But the quality of the conversation matters too. Managers need to be able to discuss workload, motivation and working preferences—not simply complete a form and assign a score.

Strengths School says its Singapore manager-training programmes teach leaders to identify differences in how team members work. The company reports that participants’ awareness of their team members’ working styles more than doubled across its programmes. It also cites a 2026 YouGov survey of 500 senior leaders, managers and employees, in which 99% rated the firm’s effectiveness in building stronger, higher-performing teams positively. These are company-reported results; the announcement does not provide the full survey questionnaire or methodology.

From appraisal scores to retention signals

For HR leaders, the central implication is that performance management and retention planning should not be treated as separate processes. An employee who consistently delivers strong results may still be at risk if the role depends heavily on activities they find exhausting. Waiting for performance to decline before intervening may mean the organization has missed earlier signals.

The approach also raises questions about how employers use employee feedback. Confidential pulse surveys, structured one-to-one conversations and workload reviews can help identify patterns that a once-a-year appraisal may miss. However, these mechanisms work only when employees trust that candid responses will not damage their standing or career prospects.

Strengths School received Bronze for Best Management Training Provider and Silver for Best Psychometric Testing Provider at Singapore’s HR Vendors of the Year 2026 awards in October. The recognition adds to the company’s positioning in manager development and workplace assessment, although awards alone do not establish the effectiveness of a particular intervention.

As Singapore employers move through appraisal and bonus cycles, the challenge is to understand not only who is delivering, but also what that delivery is costing them. A more useful performance conversation may be one that identifies employees’ capabilities alongside the conditions that allow them to sustain those capabilities over time.

Market Landscape

The story reflects a broader shift in HR from measuring employee output toward understanding the conditions that sustain performance. Engagement scores and annual ratings remain useful, but they can miss employees who are productive while experiencing high stress or burnout.

For employers, this creates a measurement challenge. Performance management systems need to account for workload, role fit, employee motivation and manager capability—not just whether objectives were achieved. The growing use of people analytics and employee listening tools may help HR teams identify these patterns, provided the data is handled confidentially and translated into practical changes.

Strengths School’s framework is one approach to structuring those conversations. Its effectiveness will depend on how consistently managers apply it and whether organizations act on what employees say.

Top Insights

  • ManpowerGroup found that 72% of surveyed Singapore workers had recently experienced burnout, highlighting the importance of retention-focused appraisal conversations.

  • Yale-linked research found that highly engaged employees can also experience burnout, with this group reporting strong intentions to leave.

  • Strengths School’s Primal Greatness framework distinguishes between work that energises employees and work they perform well but find draining.

  • Research on performance ratings suggests manager-specific rating tendencies can account for a substantial share of score variation.

  • HR teams can strengthen appraisal processes by discussing workload, motivation and role fit alongside performance outcomes.

    Join thousands of HR leaders who rely on HRTechEdge for the latest in workforce technology, AI-driven HR solutions, and strategic insights