HomeEmployee ExperienceZety Study Finds Workplace Holiday Gifts Cause Stress

Zety Study Finds Workplace Holiday Gifts Cause Stress

Workplace holiday gifting may be intended to strengthen employee relationships, but it can also create financial pressure and uncomfortable expectations. A new survey from Zety found that 43% of U.S. workers experience financial stress related to workplace holiday gift expectations, while 53% do not expect to receive a holiday gift from their employer. The findings highlight a disconnect between employee spending obligations and the recognition workers want from their organisations.

Zety Survey Highlights Financial Pressure of Workplace Holiday Gifting

Holiday celebrations are a familiar part of workplace culture, but gift exchanges can introduce financial and social expectations that not every employee is comfortable meeting. For workers already managing seasonal expenses, contributing to colleague gifts or buying presents for managers can become an additional source of pressure.

The Workplace Holiday Gifting Report from Zety examines how employees experience these expectations, what employers typically provide during the holiday season and which forms of recognition workers would actually prefer.

Based on a survey of 1,040 U.S. workers conducted on October 19, 2026, the study found that 43% of respondents experience financial stress because of workplace holiday gifting expectations. At the same time, 53% do not expect their employer to provide a holiday gift this year.

The findings raise questions for HR teams about how organisations manage workplace traditions, employee recognition and the financial boundaries between professional relationships and personal spending.

Gift exchanges can create pressure across workplace hierarchies

The survey suggests that employees feel obligations to buy gifts for colleagues and people in positions of authority.

Among respondents, 45% said they had bought or contributed towards a holiday gift for a coworker because they felt obligated. Another 35% reported doing so for a manager or supervisor. Smaller proportions said they had felt pressured to contribute gifts for a direct report or employee (11%) or the company’s CEO (8%).

These expectations can be difficult to navigate because workplace gift exchanges are often informal. Employees may feel that declining to participate could affect how colleagues perceive them, even when participation is not an official company requirement.

Zety career expert Jasmine Escalera said employees may worry that refusing to join a gift exchange could make them appear disengaged or less generous. She recommended that employers establish clear gifting guidelines and communicate that employees are not expected to spend money on colleagues.

For HR departments, this points to a relatively straightforward employee experience issue: workplace traditions should not create an implicit financial obligation.

Cash bonuses lead employee holiday wish lists

The survey also identifies a substantial difference between the gifts employees typically receive and what they would prefer.

Cash bonuses were the most preferred option, selected by 77% of respondents. However, only 34% said they typically receive one from their employer.

Additional paid time off (PTO) also showed a notable gap. While 24% would most like to receive additional PTO, only 8% said this was something they typically received.

Gift cards were more closely aligned with employee preferences, with 39% saying they typically received them and the same proportion identifying them as a preferred gift.

Other workplace benefits were less popular than their reported prevalence might suggest. A quarter of respondents typically received a holiday party or company celebration, but only 12% selected this as their preferred gift. Team meals showed a similar pattern: 24% typically received them, while 9% preferred them.

Company-branded merchandise also appeared to have limited appeal. Fifteen percent typically received branded items, compared with 5% who said they would most like to receive them.

The results suggest that employers may need to reconsider whether traditional seasonal activities reflect employee preferences or simply repeat established workplace practices.

What makes an employer gift meaningful?

The report also explored how much an employer would need to spend for a holiday gift to feel meaningful.

The most common response was between $50 and $99, selected by 26% of workers. Another 22% identified the $100–$199 range, while 17% said a gift worth less than $50 would be meaningful.

At the higher end, 8% selected $500 or more. However, 13% said monetary value would not determine whether they considered an employer gift meaningful.

These responses indicate that employee recognition does not necessarily require a uniform spending policy. Some workers may value a financial reward, while others may place greater importance on flexibility, time off or the gesture of recognition itself.

For HR leaders, the practical challenge is balancing recognition programmes with employee expectations, organisational budgets and fairness across different teams.

Recognition could influence employee sentiment in 2027

Workers also associated receiving a holiday gift with positive feelings about their employer. According to the survey, 53% said a gift would make them feel more valued, 35% said it would make them more motivated at work, and 34% said it would increase their job satisfaction. Another 18% associated receiving a gift with greater loyalty to their employer.

These responses indicate perceived employee sentiment rather than evidence that gifts directly improve retention, productivity or engagement. Nevertheless, they offer HR teams insight into how seasonal recognition may be received.

The findings are particularly relevant as employers consider how to maintain employee experience during periods of financial pressure. A recognition programme that unintentionally encourages employees to spend money on managers or colleagues could undermine the goodwill it is intended to create.

HR teams face a choice between tradition and inclusion

The broader implication is that workplace gifting policies are part of employee experience, not simply an annual social activity.

Employers can reduce unnecessary pressure by making participation voluntary, setting clear spending limits for organised exchanges and ensuring managers do not expect gifts from their teams. Organisations can also consider alternatives such as additional time off, flexible working arrangements or modest, inclusive recognition initiatives.

The Zety survey does not establish that holiday gifts directly improve business performance. Its findings instead highlight a gap between employee expectations, existing workplace practices and the financial pressure some workers experience.

For HR leaders planning employee recognition in 2027, the message is straightforward: meaningful appreciation should not depend on employees spending money to demonstrate workplace commitment.

Market Landscape

Employee experience strategies increasingly encompass workplace culture, recognition, wellbeing and financial inclusion. Seasonal gifting is a relatively small part of this wider HR agenda, but it can reveal how informal workplace practices affect employee sentiment.

Three themes emerge from the survey:

  • Financial wellbeing: Employers need to consider how workplace expectations interact with employees’ personal financial pressures.

  • Employee recognition: Workers may value direct financial benefits and additional time off more than traditional celebrations or branded merchandise.

  • Inclusive workplace culture: Clear, voluntary gifting policies can reduce pressure across reporting relationships and organisational hierarchies.

For HR technology providers, these findings also point to opportunities to support employee recognition, benefits administration and engagement programmes. However, the survey does not measure adoption of such platforms or demonstrate that technology alone can resolve workplace gifting pressures.

Top Insights

  • Zety’s survey of 1,040 U.S. workers found that 43% experience financial stress from workplace holiday gifting expectations.

  • More than half of respondents, 53%, do not expect to receive a holiday gift from their employer.

  • Cash bonuses are the most preferred holiday gift, selected by 77%, but only 34% typically receive one.

  • Additional PTO is preferred by 24% of respondents, while just 8% say they typically receive it.

  • More than half of workers (53%) say receiving an employer holiday gift would make them feel more valued.

    Join thousands of HR leaders who rely on HRTechEdge for the latest in workforce technology, AI-driven HR solutions, and strategic insights