HomeTalent AcquisitionMcLean Survey Links Career Growth to Hiring and Turnover

McLean Survey Links Career Growth to Hiring and Turnover

Career development is emerging as both a major recruitment advantage and a significant employee-retention risk, according to new benchmark reports from HR research and advisory firm McLean & Company. Its 2026 New Hire and Exit Survey findings show that career opportunities were the leading reason employees applied for and accepted jobs, while limited advancement opportunities were the most frequently cited job-related reason for voluntary departure. The findings highlight a challenge for HR teams: attracting candidates with promises of growth is only the first step; organizations must also provide credible development and progression once employees are on the job.

Career Growth Emerges as a Hiring and Retention Test

The findings expose a potential disconnect between talent attraction and the longer-term employee experience. Organizations may successfully communicate development opportunities during recruitment, but if employees cannot see a realistic path to progress after joining, that same promise can become a reason to leave.

McLean & Company’s 2026 reports examine different points in the employee lifecycle: the New Hire Survey covers hiring, acclimatization, training and development, and performance expectations, while the Exit Survey tracks factors influencing employee departures. Both reports compare benchmark data from 2023 through 2025, giving HR leaders a basis for examining how recruitment experiences relate to turnover patterns.

Career opportunity matters before and after hiring

Career opportunities were cited by 52.5% of respondents as a reason for applying for a job and by 48.3% as a reason for accepting an offer. At the other end of the employment relationship, 43.4% of departing employees cited limited career advancement as a reason for leaving.

The consistency of these rankings from 2023 to 2025 suggests that career growth is not simply a short-lived recruitment talking point. It remains a consideration across the employee lifecycle, from evaluating a prospective employer to deciding whether to stay.

For employers, the figures point to a gap worth investigating. Recruitment teams may highlight learning opportunities, promotion prospects and long-term career development to attract candidates. But those messages need to be supported by accessible training, regular development conversations, transparent promotion criteria and opportunities to take on more responsibility.

That does not mean every employee expects rapid promotion. Career progress can also involve lateral moves, broader responsibilities, specialist development, mentoring or access to projects that build new skills. The challenge for HR teams is to make those options visible and credible rather than treating advancement as a promise that will be addressed later.

Strong hiring feedback does not guarantee retention

The New Hire Survey found that hiring received the strongest positive feedback, at 94.4%. Performance expectations ranked lowest among the four measured areas, although its 86.3% positive score remained high.

The difference is notable because a positive recruitment experience can shape expectations before an employee has a realistic view of the role. Once someone joins, unclear responsibilities, limited feedback or uncertainty about what success looks like can weaken that initial impression.

The report’s findings suggest that organizations should look beyond recruitment and onboarding satisfaction. HR teams also need to understand whether employees receive adequate training, know how their performance will be assessed and can identify the skills or experience required to progress.

This has implications for managers as well as HR departments. Managers often translate formal development policies into day-to-day experiences through feedback, coaching, project assignments and discussions about future roles. If those conversations are inconsistent, employees may struggle to connect their current work with longer-term career goals.

Exit feedback can identify retention priorities

The Exit Survey adds context by separating personal reasons for departure from factors that employers may have more influence over. Personal factors appeared among the top three reasons for leaving for 53.6% of departing employees. Job-related factors were cited by 41.5%, followed by compensation at 37.3% and organizational factors at 37.2%.

These categories indicate that turnover rarely has a single explanation. Employees may leave for personal circumstances, a better financial offer, dissatisfaction with their role or concerns about leadership and workplace conditions. Career development is one area where employers can potentially make changes, but it should be considered alongside the other factors.

For HR leaders, the practical value comes from comparing exit feedback with new-hire responses and internal workforce data. If employees consistently join for career opportunities but later report limited advancement, organizations can investigate whether internal vacancies are visible, whether promotion requirements are understood and whether development plans lead to meaningful opportunities.

The reports also reinforce the importance of treating benchmark results as context rather than universal targets. McLean & Company advises HR teams to interpret the findings alongside workforce composition, organizational circumstances and feedback from their own employees. A benchmark can highlight a potential issue, but it cannot explain why a particular workforce is experiencing it.

Turning career promises into an employee experience

The findings arrive as employers face pressure to retain skills and make better use of existing talent. Internal mobility, skills development, succession planning and manager-led coaching can all contribute to a more credible career proposition. HR technology can support that work by making skills, learning opportunities, internal vacancies and development progress easier to identify, although software alone cannot create meaningful career paths.

The central message from McLean & Company’s research is that recruitment and retention should not be managed as separate activities. Organizations need to examine what attracts employees, what they experience after joining and what departing workers say was missing.

A strong hiring score may indicate that the recruitment process is working. It does not establish that employees will remain engaged or see a future with the organization. For employers seeking to reduce avoidable turnover, the more revealing question is whether the career opportunities presented to candidates become tangible development experiences once they become employees.

Market Landscape

The findings reinforce a broader shift in talent management: organizations are increasingly expected to demonstrate how employees can develop internally, not simply advertise career progression during recruitment.

Three HR priorities stand out:

  • Internal mobility: Employees need visibility into open roles, lateral moves and advancement opportunities across the organization.

  • Skills-based development: Learning programmes should connect skill acquisition with practical career opportunities and future workforce requirements.

  • Manager accountability: Managers play a central role in translating career frameworks into coaching, feedback and development plans.

HR technology platforms supporting skills intelligence, learning management, internal talent marketplaces and workforce analytics can help organizations make these opportunities more visible. However, retention still depends on whether employees experience meaningful progress, not simply whether development tools are available.

Top Insights

  • Career opportunities attracted 52.5% of job applicants and influenced 48.3% of offer acceptances, making growth a significant talent attraction factor.

  • Limited career advancement was cited by 43.4% of departing employees, the leading job-related reason for voluntary turnover.

  • New-hire hiring feedback was 94.4% positive, compared with 86.3% for performance expectations, highlighting a potential post-hiring experience gap.

  • Personal factors featured among the top three departure reasons for 53.6% of respondents, showing that turnover has multiple drivers.

  • HR leaders can connect recruitment, onboarding, development and exit feedback to identify gaps between career promises and employee experiences.

    Join thousands of HR leaders who rely on HRTechEdge for the latest in workforce technology, AI-driven HR solutions, and strategic insights