U.S. employee retention sentiment weakened in the second quarter of 2026, with the Eagle Hill Consulting Employee Retention Index falling 1.3 points to 104.2, its lowest reading in the past year. The decline suggests workers are becoming less likely to remain in their current roles over the next six months, even as confidence in employers and workplace culture continues to improve.
The latest retention data points to a more complex workforce environment than headline labor market numbers might suggest. Employees appear increasingly satisfied with their organizations’ culture and leadership direction, yet many are simultaneously reassessing whether their compensation and long-term career prospects remain competitive.
According to the second-quarter 2026 Eagle Hill Employee Retention Index, retention sentiment declined to 104.2 from the prior quarter. While the index remains above historical norms, the downward move signals a potential increase in voluntary turnover as workers gain confidence in opportunities outside their current employers.
The shift comes amid mixed signals from the broader labor market. The latest Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) reported approximately 7.6 million job openings, indicating that employment opportunities remain available for workers considering a move. At the same time, recent hiring data suggest the labor market is cooling, creating a landscape in which employers may be hiring more selectively but still competing for skilled talent.
The most significant deterioration came from the index’s Compensation Indicator, which fell 5.6 points, making it the only major retention driver to weaken during the quarter.
Key Retention Indicators (Q2 2026)
Compensation
−5.6
Sharpest decline
Job market opportunity
+1.9
External optimism rising
Organizational confidence
+0.9
Rebounded after declines
Culture
+0.3
Fourth straight increase
By contrast, the Job Market Opportunity Indicator rose 1.9 points, reflecting growing optimism about external opportunities. Employees also reported stronger confidence in their organizations and a modest improvement in workplace culture, suggesting that dissatisfaction with employers themselves is not the primary driver of emerging retention risk.
“Today’s workforce is sending employers a nuanced message,” said Melissa Jezior, president and chief executive officer of Eagle Hill Consulting. “Employees generally feel good about their organizations and workplace culture, but many are questioning whether their compensation and long-term growth opportunities are keeping pace with the market.”
Millennials emerge as the primary attrition risk
The most notable generational change occurred among Millennials, whose retention outlook fell 6.1 points, the steepest decline of any age cohort.
Millennials were the only generation to report simultaneous declines in:
-
Organizational confidence
-
Compensation satisfaction
-
Culture perceptions
At the same time, they expressed greater confidence in outside job opportunities.
That combination is particularly significant because Millennials now occupy many mid-level management, leadership, and specialized professional roles across large organizations. Elevated turnover among this group can disrupt leadership pipelines, succession planning, and institutional knowledge retention.
“Millennials now represent the backbone of leadership pipelines across many organizations,” Jezior said. “When this generation begins questioning whether to stay, employers risk losing institutional knowledge, leadership continuity, and future executives.”
Generational differences begin to narrow
Unlike earlier quarters, retention sentiment across generations became more closely aligned:
-
Gen Z: reported a modest decline in retention outlook.
-
Millennials: experienced the sharpest deterioration.
-
Gen X: became more likely to stay with current employers.
-
Baby Boomers: also showed improved retention sentiment.
The convergence suggests that retention challenges are no longer concentrated primarily among younger workers and may be spreading across broader segments of the workforce.
Why compensation is becoming more important
The sharp decline in the Compensation Indicator suggests employees are evaluating more than current salary levels. Workers appear increasingly focused on:
-
Total rewards and benefits
-
Future earning potential
-
Career advancement opportunities
-
Long-term financial growth
-
Internal mobility prospects
As perceptions of external opportunities improve, employees may be comparing their current compensation trajectory against what they believe they could obtain elsewhere, even in a moderating labor market.
For HR leaders, this creates a different challenge than the post-pandemic hiring surge. Retention may depend less on broad cultural initiatives alone and more on demonstrating a credible path for compensation growth, skill development, and career progression.
What the findings mean for employers
The research suggests that organizations should avoid assuming that a slower hiring environment will automatically reduce turnover risk. Employees continue to evaluate the full employment experience, including development opportunities, leadership quality, recognition, flexibility, and future career prospects.
Industry analysts have increasingly emphasized the connection between career growth and retention. Gartner has identified internal mobility and skills development as critical components of workforce resilience, while McKinsey & Company has highlighted career progression and meaningful work as key drivers of employee commitment in knowledge-based roles.
For HR technology vendors and enterprise employers, the findings reinforce growing investment in:
-
Skills intelligence platforms
-
Internal talent marketplaces
-
Career pathing tools
-
AI-driven learning recommendations
-
Manager enablement and coaching systems
-
Total rewards transparency
Those capabilities are increasingly viewed as strategic infrastructure for retention rather than optional employee experience enhancements.
A workforce that likes the company but may still leave
Perhaps the most important takeaway from the Eagle Hill data is that strong culture alone may no longer guarantee retention. Employees can feel positively about their organization and still decide to explore external opportunities if they believe compensation, advancement, or future growth prospects are stronger elsewhere.
For employers, that creates a more nuanced retention challenge: maintaining the cultural gains achieved in recent years while proving that staying offers a competitive long-term career and financial proposition.
As workforce mobility begins to rise from historically strong retention levels, organizations that align compensation, development, leadership quality, and career opportunity are likely to be better positioned to retain critical talent through the next phase of labor market change.
Market Landscape
The Employee Retention Index reflects a broader shift in workforce strategy toward retention, internal mobility, and skills development. Gartner reports that organizations are increasingly investing in talent marketplaces, career pathing, and manager enablement to reduce voluntary turnover, while McKinsey & Company continues to identify career growth, meaningful work, and leadership quality as major drivers of employee commitment. HR technology providers are responding with AI-powered workforce analytics, compensation planning, learning platforms, and employee experience tools designed to improve retention and workforce planning.
Top Insights
-
Eagle Hill’s Employee Retention Index fell 1.3 points to 104.2, reaching its lowest level in a year and signaling a higher likelihood of voluntary turnover over the next six months.
-
Compensation concerns drove the decline, with the Compensation Indicator dropping 5.6 points while confidence in external job opportunities rose 1.9 points.
-
Millennials emerged as the largest retention risk, posting a 6.1-point decline and becoming more optimistic about opportunities outside their current employers.
-
Organizational confidence and workplace culture improved, suggesting employees generally like their employers even as they question compensation and long-term growth prospects.
-
Retention strategies increasingly require career development, leadership quality, and total rewards alignment, not just strong workplace culture or engagement programs.
Business Wire, a Berkshire Hathaway company, is the global leader in press release distribution and regulatory disclosure. Public relations, investor relations, public policy and marketing professionals rely on Business Wire for secure and accurate distribution of market-moving news and multimedia. Founded in 1961, Business Wire is a trusted source for news organizations, journalists, investment professionals and regulatory authorities, delivering news directly into editorial systems and leading online news sources via its multi-patented NX network. Business Wire’s global newsrooms are available to meet the needs of communications professionals and news media worldwide.
